| C. Van Kirk | 1811 – 1815 | 
| Charles Williams | 1815 – 1819 | 
| Charles Miller | 1819 – 1821 | 
| John Smeltzer | 1821 – 1823 | 
| Jolm Crowley | 1823 – 1827 | 
| T. Butler Lewis | 1827 – 1829 | 
| Jolm Crowley | 1829 – 1833 | 
| J. H. Hutchinson | 1833 – 1837 | 
| Samuel Morrison | 1837 – 1841 | 
| Joseph C. Maginity | 1841 – 1845 | 
| Samuel Morrison | 1845 – 1849 | 
| Samuel B. Crowley | 1849 – 1853 | 
| Richard Lanning | 1853 – 1855 | 
| W. H. H. Price | 1855 – 1857 | 
| David Rodahaver | 1857 – 1861 | 
| John Hesket | 1861 – 1865 | 
| James Sells | 1865 – 1868 | 
| Thomas Platt | 1868 – 1869 | 
| Joshua H. Carr | 1869 – 1873 | 
| John Lennon | 1873 – 1877 | 
| Jacob Severns | 1877 – 1881 | 
| Andy Miller | 1881 – 1885 | 
| J. B. Manner | 1885 – 1889 | 
| Charles Craig | 1889 – 1893 | 
| Henry Clark | 1897 – 1899 | 
| Archie Hedge | 1899 – 1903 | 
| Hamilton Browning | 1903 – 1908 | 
| A.C. McDonald | 1908 – 1912 | 
| George Pharion | 1912 – 1916 | 
| Earl Cullison | 1916 – 1920 | 
| Ernest Darr | 1920 – 1924 | 
| Harold Marquand | 1924 – 1928 | 
| J. R. Stoffer | 1928 – 1932 | 
| Jay Abbott | 1932 – 1948 | 
| Gilbert F. Kempf | 1948 – 1956 | 
| William Hoop Jr. | 1957 – 1980 | 
| David A. Corbett | 1980 – 2000 | 
| Timothy L. Rogers | 2001 – 2021 | 
| James A. Crawford | 2021 – | 


